I've been thinking about putting together this massive post since the outset of the NBA postseason, and I'm finally getting around to it now. I watch and talk about basketball so often that it's really a necessity. Of course when we undertake a task like this, we run into the following issues:
1. What are the rankings based upon? Just this season? The past handful of years? Entire careers?
2. What carries more weight, cold statistics or the eye test?
3. How do we compare guards to forwards, forwards to centers, etc?
Well, at the end of the day, these are the questions I'm asking myself when evaluating an NBA player:
• How unique is the player? Are there a bunch of guys just like him?
• Can he create his own shot?
• Does he have the killer instinct? Yes, no or maybe?
• Is his game defined? Relative to that, does he play consistently?
• Does the consistency of his game contribute directly to his team’s success?
• Is he a two-way player?
• Have they been able to stay healthy?
• Are they consistently aggressive or do they play passively at times?
• Do they WANT it?
• Are they a boom-or-bust player? Too much of a wild card?
Without further ado, in the words of the diabolical and twister Joker, "Here...we...go."
200. Meyers Leonard
What I like: Leonard is a big, strong kid who hustles and has made a concerted effort to improve his offensive game. He added a perfectly adequate three-point shot to his repertoire this season, to go along with his activity on the offensive glass and reasonable ability to finish around the rim. He's also active and physical defensively, if not entirely skilled.
What I don't like: Low ceiling. He deserved more playing time from head coach Terry Stotts this season, but even at 22-30 minutes per night his ceiling would be around 12-13 points and 7-8 rebounds per game.
199. Brandan Wright
What I like: Wright was one of the most consistent and useful back-up centers in the NBA when he played behind Tyson Chandler (and last season, Samuel Dalembert) in Dallas. He is a limited off-the-ball offensive player a la DeAndre Jordan, Mason Plumlee or more of the like, but he finishes the plays he's paid to finish. He's a coordinated pick-and-roll lob player with good springs and long arms. Defensively he's a good shot blocker with limited bulk to guard post-ups.
What I don't like: Jeff Hornacek didn't seem to find him very useful in Phoenix. Devin Harris was Wright's pick-and-roll lob partner in Dallas, but no one was really looking for him that way in Phoenix. It just goes to show you, if a guy doesn't have one-on-one offensive game, he can be a forgotten man on teams without skillful and/or willing passers.
198. Otto Porter
What I like: Here's a guy who looked absolutely lost for most of his first year and a half as a pro, then all of a sudden he seemed to figure things out. Some credit goes to the savvy tutelage of the great Paul Pierce. The rest gets attributed to Porter's length, athleticism, energy, willingness to attack/cut/move without the ball and the pure basketball ability that earned him a high lottery selection.
What I don't like: Otto needs to work on his triples if he wants to be an all-around offensive threat at the wing position. His ballhandling is suspect as well.
What I like: Raw size and surprising ability. Len is not a clumsy Hasheem Thabeet type, despite his legitimate height and potentially-gawky length. He can catch and finish in deep, and his touch is better than I expected it to be. Defensively he's a shot blocker who needs to work on his lateral movement and team rotations. Len ran into a lot of the same problems as Brandan Wright at #199 -- the Suns' rotating guards throughout the season (Dragic, Bledsoe, Thomas and Knight) aren't generally looking to spoon feed their bigs. I suppose that's kind of the nature of the league in general, now.
What I don't like: Lack of defensive quickness and no jump shooting game at this point. We'll see if he works on that.
196. Kosta Koufos
What I like: The guy's a pro. He's not particularly spectacular in any way, but he plays hard, gets in solid position on both ends of the floor and finishes nicely at close range. He was a totally serviceable starting center during his days as a Denver Nugget. Nowadays, he's exactly the kind of player you want as your back-up big.
What I don't like: His once quick feet aren't as quick as they used to be. Showing some decline with age, but is still a useful giant.
195. Beno Udrih
What I like: "Beno Draino" knows his game. Protect the ball, come off high screens and knock down mid-range lefty jumpers. He's reliable, experienced and isn't going to kill you when your ace point guard is off the floor. I always find value in consistency and a player with a defined game, even if he's a pure role player.
What I don't like: Opposing point guards salivate when they see Beno in front of them. He isn't big, strong or particularly fleet of foot at this stage in his solid NBA career.
194. CJ McCollum
What I like: Here's a guy who very quickly redefined his offensive game. Throughout his rookie season and about half of his sophomore campaign, it seemed like McCollum was trying to be a pure shooting guard because that's what the organization told him they needed. What's the problem with that? He's not a pure three-point shooter and he's not really a comfortable catch-and-shoot player. McCollum really came into his own when he began utilizing his off-the-bounce quickness and driving relentlessly -- both right and left -- to the rim. An argument could be made that he was the Blazers' best player in their unsuccessful postseason series against the Grizzlies.
What I don't like: I don't know if C.J.'s short-term success was a fluke. It's too small of a sample size to really make a determination. I'll have to see more consistency over time to move him up.
193. Austin Rivers
What I like: Like Otto Porter and C.J. McCollum, Rivers decided to suddenly play his best basketball in the playoffs. That definitely isn't a bad thing. When Rivers realized he could use his size and quickness to attack the paint while more established players like Blake Griffin, JJ Redick and Jamal Crawford drew the majority of the defensive attention, he became an extremely valuable reserve for his father's team. We'll see if he can carry that new found confidence over to next season.
What I don't like: Rivers has actually been a negative contributor for most of his short NBA career. He has spent a lot of time hurting his teams with indecisiveness and wildly inconsistent perimeter shooting. We'll see which Rivers shows up in 2015-16.
192. Chris Andersen
What I like: He may look like an unreliable loose cannon, but on the court, that couldn't be further from the truth. In a way, "Birdman's" look is a calculated bit of misdirection. When given the playing time, knowledgeable NBA enthusiasts have always considered him one of the premier shotblockers in the game; however, he can also be useful on the other end of the court with his lob-catching ability, offensive rebounding and "50/50 plays," as Coach Spo would say. He's a true team guy.
What I don't like: Another "limited" or "low ceiling" player, as I have dubbed others. Creates little to no offense on his own and makes little impact on the game when his hustle level is below 100%.
191. JJ Hickson
What I like: When healthy and surrounded by the right cast of characters, Hickson can be a productive and sometimes-explosive flex big. He finishes hard -- often with two hands -- at the cup, makes athletic plays and dominates the glass at times. The key to that sentence, of course, is "at times."
What I don't like: Seems to get injured often and also appears to wear out his welcome with his coaches and/or teammates. He gets major run for stretches, but eventually becomes more of a 7th or 8th man for his team(s). Would only be a starter on three or four teams, at most.
190. Jason Terry
What I like: "Jet" is a winner...always has been. I thought he was finished when he was on my Nets last season, but then he bounced back as a solid contributor for a very formidable Rockets team this year. At this stage in his superb NBA career (now third all time in three-pointers made), Terry's offensive game is pretty simple: Shoot threes when open and use the pump fake and threat of the three as a gateway to the paint and his patented pull-up jumper.
What I don't like: He was never an elite defender, and now with diminished foot speed he's certainly below average. That's surely an issue when he has to guard guys like Steph Curry, Chris Paul, Mike Conley and Tony Parker out west.
EDITOR'S NOTE: I just realized there's no way I'll ever finish this thing, with descriptions. Here's the rest in list form, 1 to 189:
LeBron James 1
Russell Westbrook 2
Stephen Curry 3
James Harden 4
Anthony Davis 5
Chris Paul 6
Kevin Durant 7
Blake Griffin 8
Kyrie Irving 9
DeMarcus
Cousins 10
John
Wall 11
LaMarcus
Aldridge 13
Dwight
Howard 14
Brook
Lopez 15
Marc
Gasol 16
Carmelo Anthony 17
Tim
Duncan 18
Mike
Conley 19
Monta
Ellis 20
Chris Bosh 21
Pau
Gasol 22
Kevin
Love 23
Gordon
Hayward 24
Damian
Lillard 25
Jeff
Teague 26
Kawhi
Leonard 28
Rudy
Gay 29
Al
Horford 30
Zach
Randolph 31
Dwyane Wade 32
Nikola Vucevic 33
Derrick
Rose 34
Joe Johnson 35
Dirk Nowitzki 36
Tony Parker 37
Paul Millsap 38
DeMar DeRozan 39
Bradley
Beal 40
Wesley
Matthews 41
Tyreke
Evans 42
Al
Jefferson 43
Ty
Lawson 44
Goran
Dragic 45
Brandon
Jennings 46
Greg
Monroe 47
Khris
Middleton 48
Eric
Bledsoe 49
Isaiah
Thomas 50
Draymond
Green 51
Kyle
Korver 52
Kemba
Walker 53
DeAndre
Jordan 54
Reggie
Jackson 55
Brandon
Knight 56
Paul
George 57
Jamal
Crawford 58
Kobe
Bryant 59
DeMarre
Carroll 60
Deron
Williams 61
Andre
Drummond 62
Hassan
Whiteside 63
Kevin
Martin 64
Enes
Kanter 65
Andrew
Wiggins 66
Kyle
Lowry 67
Derrick
Favors 68
Darren
Collison 69
Serge
Ibaka 70
Victor
Oladipo 71
Michael
Carter-Williams 72
Eric
Gordon 73
Markieff
Morris 74
Ricky
Rubio 75
Kenneth
Faried 76
Chandler
Parsons 77
Rudy
Gobert 78
Paul
Pierce 79
George
Hill 80
Tobias
Harris 81
Danny
Green 82
C.J.
Miles 83
Jordan
Clarkson 84
Tristan
Thompson 85
Timofey Mozgov 86
Harrison
Barnes 87
Joakim
Noah 88
J.J.
Redick 89
Boris
Diaw 90
Lou
Williams 91
Marcin
Gortat 92
Josh
Smith 93
Nicolas
Batum 94
Arron
Afflalo 95
Mo
Williams 96
Luol
Deng 97
Nene
Hilario 98
Ryan
Anderson 99
Mike
Dunleavy 100
Jarrett
Jack 101
Tony
Allen 102
Nerlens
Noel 103
Taj
Gibson 104
Terrence
Jones 105
Andrea
Bargnani 106
Thaddeus
Young 107
Courtney
Lee 108
Jeff
Green 110
David
West 111
Tyson
Chandler 112
Andre Iguodala 113
J.R.
Smith 114
Jordan
Hill 115
Andrew
Bogut 116
Jared Sullinger 117
Jrue
Holiday 118
Evan
Turner 119
Amir
Johnson 120
Patty
Mills 121
Carlos
Boozer 122
Jodie
Meeks 123
Wilson
Chandler 124
Jusuf
Nurkic 125
Trevor
Ariza 126
Giannis
Antetekounmpo 127
Jonas
Valanciunas 128
O.J.
Mayo 129
Rodney
Stuckey 130
Brandon
Bass 131
Robin
Lopez 132
Corey
Brewer 133
Michael
Kidd-Gilchrist 134
D.J.
Augustin 135
Gary
Neal 136
P.J.
Tucker 137
Avery
Bradley 138
Elfrid
Payton 139
Robert
Covington 140
Matt
Barnes 141
Ersan
Ilyasova 142
Patrick
Beverley 143
Manu
Ginobili 144
Marcus
Morris 145
Gerald
Henderson 146
Greivis
Vasquez 147
Gorgui
Dieng 148
Danilo
Gallinari 149
Dion
Waiters 150
Gerald
Green 151
Kelly
Olynyk 152
Luis
Scola 153
Bojan
Bogdanovic 154
Aaron
Brooks 155
Alan
Anderson 156
Mike
Scott 157
Nikola
Mirotic 158
Omer
Asik 159
Marco
Belinelli 160
Jae
Crowder 161
Zaza
Pachulia 162
Zach
LaVine 163
Marresse
Speights 164
Donatas
Motiejunas 165
Leandro
Barbosa 166
Kentavious
Caldwell-Pope 168
C.J.
Watson 169
Wayne
Ellington 170
Amare
Stoudemire 171
Lance
Stephenson 172
Iman
Shumpert 173
Tyler
Zeller 174
Pero
Antic 175
Marcus
Smart 176
John
Henson 177
Quincy
Pondexter 178
Shaun Livingston 179
Jeremy Lin 180
J.J.
Barea 181
Rajon
Rondo 182
Jerryd
Bayless 183
Tony
Wroten 184
Trey
Burke 185
Nick
Young 186
Kent
Bazemore 187
Randy
Foye 188
Will
Barton 189